Ice, Ice, Maybe… But probably not. The science has gone cold on ice baths for recovery.

Recent science tells us the supposed benefits of ice post-exercise are not all they’re cracked up to be, and that the short-term shrinkage isn’t giving any long-term gains.

 

ice bathImage Credit: Tomas Tomas via Flickr

Sprinters, climbers and café racers are all looking for the best way to recover before their next training session, competition or speed-sign sprint. In the past, it was widely recommended that ice baths post-training or competing was an easy and cost-effective way to do this. Just like a standard bath – only crunchy.

 

‘I read this article that said I should do it’

A bunch of websites targeting athletes from all walks, runs and powerlifts of life have claimed that using ice baths will increase blood circulation, reduce inflammation, and even improve overall muscle function… Unfortunately, new research suggests the only change you’ll see is a reduced hot water bill.

 

Scientists have just made their way to the deep end

Ice baths have been put under the blow torch over the last few years from a whole squad of researchers. The aim was to wash away some of the not so solid facts on just how beneficial post exercise cold water immersion can be. They looked at the effect on blood circulation, inflammatory markers (a good indicator for how much ‘ow my legs’ you feel the days after a hard session), and the overall effect on exercise performance in the days post ice bathing.

 

The Cold Truth

All credible recent studies have agreed that cold water’s effect size on recovery is about the same as it’s freezing point (0 for those playing at home). Not only has the recent research shown that jumping in an ice bath after each training session is a waste of time (and water), it might put a freeze on your recovery all together.

 

Surely it can’t hurt, right?

Wrong. Some studies showed ice baths decreased blood circulation (makes sense when you watch an ice-bath victim quickly resemble the skin-tone of a snowman). This is a big no-no as it prevents muscle repair and removal of nasty by-products after high intensity exercise. Even if it lived up to the claims of reducing inflammation this wouldn’t be a win. Inflammation within muscles is the necessary evil which then allows for muscle repair and rebuilding, resulting in those ever-elusive gains. Lose the inflammation, lose the gains.

 

No gains.jpgImage Credit: Chris Stymac via Flickr

I find it a little odd that ice baths have been used unnecessarily for so long, especially considering there are no obvious brands keeping the myth afloat for their own financial benefit (the main players making big money off ice sales are not working in the sports industry…).

ice dealerImage Credit: Hello Chicago via Flickr

Best to bin the bath post-exercise and go with little recovery spin to the café followed by a nice cold drink from your esky full of fresh, unused ice.

 

Still haven’t warmed to the facts? Try these:

https://www.auckland.ac.nz/en/about/news-events-and-notices/news/news-2017/02/ice-baths-no-good-for-muscle-recovery.html

http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20161209-do-athletes-need-to-take-ice-baths

https://www.outsideonline.com/1971446/recovery-ice-bath-isnt-always-such-good-idea

 

I’m into my last few training days before flying to NZ to kick off a big racing block. An ice bath would definitely be welcomed at the end of some big days on the road in the low 40s but I’ll have to cop the heat to max out those gains in preparation for the next few races. Until then, I’ll keep reading the research papers so you can spend more time on the bike.

Cheers,

Cyrus

 

© Cyrus Monk 2019

Request a Topic

Want to know the results of research on a particular topic of interest? Any questions about a supplement, food or intervention you’ve heard is the next big thing? Leave a question or a topic suggestion in the comments and I’ll sift through the papers for you.

A$10.00

Advertisements

Antioxidants or Antibenefits? Why Free Radicals are the unsung hero for athletes

‘Antioxidants’ is a word we see smattered all over breakfast cereal and juice packaging, but new research is telling us that athletes might need to lay off the goji berry extract if they want the most out of their training.

antioxidantsImage Credit: PracticalCures.com

The goodies

Antioxidants have received a more than decent wrap from the food and supplements industry. They’re talked up as being able to help with all kinds of medical conditions, from helping with eye-sight and joint function, to preventing Alzheimer’s disease and cancer.  This hype is great for the companies selling products rich in antioxidants, but it pays to know a little about just what antioxidants are and how they work before you buy a few hundred punnets of blueberries.

The baddies

Every hero needs a villain, and in this tale the villains are a type of free radical known as reactive oxygen species. Reactive oxygen species oxidise stuff, this is bad. Antioxidants antioxidize stuff, this is good.

The story should be straightforward, more heroes and less villains and the greater good prevails? Not quite, like any good superhero story this one has a twist… When it comes to exercise our radical villains play an important role, just enough to make you think twice about whether to barrack for them or the hero.

free radical‘Free Radical’ by Kelly Frew via Flickr

What happens when you train?

Radicals build up within the muscle during intense exercise. Basically, the more oxygen consumed by the muscle, the more oxidative stress from reactive oxygen species (radicals). The stress caused from the radicals then causes damage to the muscle. Now this damage isn’t exactly making our villain sound any more heroic, however, these small amounts of damage are crucial for athletes to see the benefits from their training.

Free Radicals are actually pretty radical

The presence of these radicals causes the release of signals within the muscle telling the muscle to repair itself and better prepare for future oxidative attacks. Think of it like a bunch of bad guys attacking a city. The bad guys don’t do enough to destroy the city completely, the city rallies together, fixes the broken buildings and builds some better walls to defend against the next attack.

Free Radicals do a little damage to the muscle during training so the muscle can repair and become better equipped for the main competition.

Castle.jpgImage Credit: Destinations Journey via Flickr

So, radicals aren’t all bad, but what’s wrong with antioxidants?

If there’s too many heroes around, the villains never make it to the city. This is fine if you’re happy in a small town that will never face attack. But if you’re an athlete you’re striving for a big, powerful fortress that can cope with anything. If the muscle never faces oxidative stress then there is nothing to promote repair and improvement. In the presence of too many antioxidants all that hard training could be going to waste!

I just ate a cranberry; will I have any muscle left by tomorrow?

As is the case with almost all nutrients in the diet: moderation is key. There is still a long list of benefits associated with antioxidants. This new research suggests for athletes to get the most out of their sessions it may be best to avoid overdoing the vitamin supplements and go easy on the goji berries in your post-workout smoothie.

goji berriesGoji Berries. Image Credit: Leslie Degner via Flickr

Further reading:

http://www.abc.net.au/science/articles/2014/11/12/4124033.htm

http://sciencebasedmedicine.org/antioxidants-and-exercise-more-harm-than-good/

https://medlineplus.gov/antioxidants.html

http://www.webmd.com/food-recipes/20-common-foods-most-antioxidants

 

My first race with the team will be the Gravel and Tar Classic next week in New Zealand. Hopefully a good week of training and watching the antioxidant intake will have me ready to go! Until then, I’ll keep reading the research papers so you can spend more time on the bike.

Cheers,

Cyrus

© Cyrus Monk 2019